Estimated reading time — 18 minutes

The photograph looked ordinary at first.

On a quiet Saturday morning, the small neighborhood yard sale did not look very exciting. A few folding tables stood on the sidewalk in front of a modest brick house. Cardboard boxes sat under the tables. Old blankets were spread across the grass with random objects placed on top. The air smelled faintly of cut grass and warm pavement, and the sun hung in the sky with the calm brightness that often comes with late morning.

Most of the items were the usual things people tried to get rid of when they cleaned out a house. There were coffee mugs with faded designs, stacks of magazines with curled edges, and a few old paperback books with cracked spines. A lamp leaned awkwardly against a box filled with kitchen utensils. A bundle of tangled Christmas lights sat beside several dusty picture frames that probably once hung proudly on someone’s wall.

Only a few people walked by the sale. Most slowed down just long enough to glance at the tables before continuing down the sidewalk. To them it was simply another small yard sale that did not hold anything worth stopping for.

Near one of the tables sat a worn cardboard box filled with old paper items. Photographs, postcards, greeting cards, and folded letters were piled together in no particular order. Some of the photographs were bent at the corners. Others had yellowed with age. The box looked like a quiet collection of memories that once mattered to someone but had now been forgotten.

Emily had not planned to stop at the sale at all. She had been walking down the street with her hands in the pockets of her light jacket. She was early for a meeting with a friend at a cafe a few blocks away, and she still had nearly forty minutes to spare. When she noticed the tables set up along the sidewalk, she slowed down.

“Well,” she murmured to herself, “I guess I have time to look around.”

She stepped closer and began looking through the items. Her movements were slow and casual. She picked up a mug with a faded blue flower painted on the side, turned it around in her hands for a moment, and set it back down. She flipped through a stack of magazines from the nineteen nineties, glancing at the colorful covers before placing them neatly back in the pile.

Nothing really caught her attention. A middle aged woman sat behind one of the tables in a folding chair. She held a paper cup of coffee in one hand and watched the few people passing by with a polite but tired smile.

“Morning,” the woman said as Emily approached the table.

“Morning,” Emily replied with a friendly nod.

Emily continued looking over the items until her eyes drifted toward the cardboard box filled with photographs. Something about the box drew her attention. Maybe it was curiosity. Maybe it was simply because everything else looked uninteresting. She crouched down beside the box and began flipping slowly through the pictures. There were dozens of them. Most of the photographs showed simple family moments. Birthday parties. Children standing beside decorated Christmas trees. Couples smiling in front of houses or cars that now looked very old.

One photograph showed a young couple cutting a wedding cake while several guests clapped and smiled behind them. Another showed a group of children running through a sprinkler in someone’s backyard while water sparkled in the sunlight. The photographs felt strange in a quiet way. Each one captured a moment that had once been important to someone. People had laughed in those moments. They had talked, celebrated, and taken pictures so they could remember those days later. Now those memories were sitting in a cardboard box for strangers to sort through.

Emily picked up a colorful postcard showing Niagara Falls. The bright blue water and white mist faded from age. Beneath it she found a photograph of a birthday party that looked like it had taken place in the nineteen seventies. Several children sat around a table wearing pointed party hats while a chocolate cake waited in the center. She set that picture aside and continued searching through the box. Then she saw the photograph.

It rested near the bottom of the pile, partly hidden beneath the postcard and the birthday picture. At first it looked like just another old photograph. It was black and white and slightly curled at the corners. The paper had a faint yellow tint that old photographs often develop after many years. Emily pulled it out and held it closer to her face. The photograph showed six people standing beside a lake. It looked like a simple vacation picture that someone might take during a peaceful afternoon.

Three men stood in the back row. Two women sat on a wooden bench in front of them. A young boy stood beside the bench holding what appeared to be a fishing pole. Everyone in the picture was smiling. They looked relaxed in the way people often do when someone is about to take a photograph. Emily could easily imagine the moment when the picture had been taken. Someone behind the camera probably said something like, “Alright everyone, hold still.” One of the men might have laughed and adjusted his stance. The boy might have asked, “Do I look okay?” One of the women could have replied, “Stand up straight and smile.”

Then the camera clicked. Behind them the lake stretched out quietly. Sunlight reflected across the smooth water, and tall trees surrounded the shore. The entire scene looked peaceful and calm, like the kind of place where people could spend hours relaxing without worrying about anything. Emily studied the photograph for a moment.

“Nice place,” she said quietly.

She was about to put the photograph back into the box when something in the background caught her eye. Her gaze drifted toward the trees behind the group of smiling people. At first she thought she was looking at a shadow or perhaps a dark shape between the trunks. The photograph was old and slightly grainy, so the details were not perfectly clear. Emily frowned slightly and leaned closer.

“Huh,” she whispered.

She tilted the photograph, so the light struck it more directly. That was when she realized the shape was a man. He stood far back among the trees. Part of his body was hidden behind one of the trunks, and the shade made most of him appear dark. However, his face was pale enough to stand out clearly against the darker background. He was staring directly at the camera. He was not smiling or posing. He was simply watching. Emily felt a faint shiver run across her shoulders.

“That’s strange,” she murmured under her breath.

She looked more closely at the photograph and noticed something else that felt even stranger. Everyone standing by the lake was dressed for warm weather. The women wore light summer dresses. The men wore short sleeve shirts. The boy standing beside the bench was barefoot, his toes resting on the grass. But the man in the trees wore a long dark coat. The coat looked heavy, like something meant for cold weather. It hung straight down and reached nearly to his knees. Emily studied the image again.

“Why would someone wear that in summer?” she asked softly.

The woman behind the table glanced over.

“Did you say something?” the yard sale woman asked.

Emily looked up quickly and shook her head. “Oh, no,” she said with a small smile. “Just thinking out loud.”

The woman chuckled quietly. “Happens to me all the time.”

Emily turned the photograph over to see if anything had been written on the back. There was nothing there. No names or date, not even the location. Just blank paper. Emily tapped the edge of the photograph lightly against her finger. The uneasy feeling returned, though she could not explain why.

“Two dollars for the whole box,” the woman suddenly said from behind the table.

Emily looked up in surprise. “For everything in it?”

“Yep,” the woman replied with a shrug. “I just want it gone.”

Emily looked down at the photograph again. The man in the trees seemed to stare up from the picture with that same still expression. Curiosity tugged at her thoughts.

“Alright,” Emily said after a moment. “I’ll take it.”

She handed the woman two dollars, and the woman passed the cardboard box across the table.

“Thank you,” the woman said.

“You’re welcome,” Emily replied.

She lifted the box and carried it with her as she continued down the street. Later that night Emily sat at the small kitchen table inside her apartment. The room was quiet except for the gentle hum of the refrigerator and the occasional sound of a car passing outside. A warm cup of tea rested beside her hand. The cardboard box sat on the table in front of her. She reached inside and pulled out the photograph again. Placing it beneath the bright kitchen light, she studied the image carefully.

The people by the lake looked even clearer now. Their faces showed relaxed happiness, the kind people often feel when they are away from work and everyday worries. The boy’s smile was wide and slightly uneven, as though he had recently lost a baby tooth.

“They look like they were having a good day,” Emily said softly.

She imagined the conversations that might have happened before the photograph was taken.

One of the men might have said, “The fish are biting today.”

Another could have laughed and replied, “You say that every time we come out here.”

The boy might have asked excitedly, “Can I try fishing next?”

One of the women could have smiled and warned him, “Just be careful not to fall in the lake.”

Emily smiled faintly as she imagined the scene. Then her attention shifted back toward the trees. The man stood there exactly as before; watching. The longer Emily looked at him, the more uncomfortable she felt. His face seemed too still. The rest of the photograph felt almost alive in a strange way. She could imagine the wind moving through the leaves or hear the soft sound of water touching the shore.

But the man in the trees felt different. He looked frozen, like he did not belong in the picture at all. Emily leaned closer.

“Who are you?” she asked quietly.

Of course there was no answer. After a moment she sighed and leaned back in her chair.

“This is silly,” she told herself. “It’s just an old picture.”

Still, the uneasy feeling lingered in the back of her mind. She opened a small notebook lying on the table and slid the photograph between two pages.

“There,” she said softly. “That’s enough of that for tonight.”

She closed the notebook, turned off the kitchen light, and walked toward her bedroom. The apartment remained silent except for the soft mechanical hum of appliances and the distant sounds of traffic outside. Emily climbed into bed and pulled the blanket over herself. At first sleep came slowly. Her mind kept drifting back to the photograph. She pictured the calm lake. The smiling people, and the man standing among the trees. Eventually she drifted into sleep, but the night did not pass peacefully. Several times she woke for no clear reason. Once she thought she heard a faint noise somewhere in the apartment. Another time she woke suddenly as if someone had whispered her name.

Each time she lay still in the darkness, listening. Her heart beat slightly faster than normal, and she felt a strange urge to walk into the kitchen and look at the photograph again. The feeling was strong, but she stayed in bed.

“It’s just a picture,” she whispered to herself in the darkness.

Eventually she fell asleep again. Morning sunlight filled the apartment through the windows. Emily stretched and yawned as she sat up in bed. For a moment she forgot about the photograph completely. Then she remembered. She walked into the kitchen and began making coffee. The notebook still rested on the table exactly where she had left it the night before. Emily glanced at it for a moment and then shook her head with a small laugh.

“I can’t believe that bothered me,” she said to herself.

She poured her coffee and took a sip before looking once more at the notebook.

“It was just an old picture,” she said. “Nothing more.”

Emily stood at the kitchen counter for a moment, holding her cup of coffee and staring at the closed notebook on the table. Morning light filled the apartment through the window. The quiet normal feeling of the day made the strange thoughts from the night before seemed a little silly. She let out a small breath and shook her head.

“I really let that get to me,” she said softly to herself.

She walked over to the table and pulled the notebook closer. Her fingers rested on the cover for a moment. She told herself there was nothing strange about an old photograph. Her imagination had probably filled in details that were never there. Still, she opened the notebook. When she turned to the page where she had placed the photograph, something made her pause. The man looked different. Emily stared at the photograph for several seconds before she understood why. He looked closer. Not by much, just a little. Before, the man had been standing behind a thick tree trunk. Only half of his body had been visible in the shadow. The tree had hidden most of his coat and part of his face. Now he stood slightly to the side of the trunk. More of his coat could be seen now. More of his face too. Emily leaned forward slowly, bringing the picture closer to her eyes. Her eyebrows pulled together.

“That is not possible,” she said quietly.

She lifted the photograph toward the kitchen light so she could see every detail clearly. The bright light shone across the glossy surface of the paper. Maybe the shadows looked different in the daylight. Maybe she had simply remembered it wrong the night before. Memory could play tricks on people. She stared at the photograph carefully. The smiling group by the lake looked exactly the same. The three men stood behind the bench. The two women sat calmly in front of them. The young boy still held the fishing pole and smiled with that wide, uneven grin. But the man in the trees had changed position. The longer Emily looked, the more certain she became. He had somehow moved. A faint, crawling feeling slowly traveled up the back of her neck. Emily shook her head quickly.

“This is ridiculous,” she muttered.

She forced herself to stop staring at the picture. She slid it out of the notebook and placed it inside one of the kitchen drawers. Then she shut the drawer firmly.

“There,” she said.

She grabbed her bag, finished her coffee, and left for work. All day she tried not to think about it. She sat at her desk, answered emails, and worked through the normal routine of her job. Coworkers talked nearby about weekend plans and television shows. Phones rang. People walked through the hallways. Everything felt normal. But the thought kept returning. The photograph. The man standing in the trees. Standing closer, and watching. Emily tried to convince herself that she had imagined it. Her memory must have been wrong. She had only looked at the photograph for a short time the night before. Her mind had probably filled in the rest. Still, the image of the pale face hidden among the trees kept slipping back into her thoughts.

By the time the workday ended she felt tired and uneasy. When Emily returned home that evening, the first thing she did was walk into the kitchen. The apartment was quiet, just as it had been the night before. Her eyes moved toward the drawer. For a moment she simply stood there. Then she slowly pulled it open. The photograph laid exactly where she had left it. She picked it up and carried it to the table. The overhead light shone brightly above her as she placed the photograph flat on the surface.

As soon as her eyes looked at the picture, her stomach tightened. The man had moved again. This time the change was obvious. He was no longer behind the tree. Now he stood in clear view between two trunks several feet closer to the group by the lake. Emily felt her hands grow cold as she leaned closer to the photograph. His pale face was clearer now, still staring directly toward the camera. Her heart began beating faster.

“No,” she whispered.

She flipped the photograph over quickly and examined the back again. It was still blank. Emily turned the photograph back over and looked at the corners of the paper. She ran her fingers along the edges as if she expected to find a hidden seam or a place where the picture had been cut and replaced.

But there was nothing. It was the same old photograph. But the man kept getting closer. Emily slowly lowered herself into the chair at the table. The room suddenly felt colder than before. She stared at the photograph for a long time. The group by the lake continued smiling at the camera as if nothing had changed. Only the man in the trees had moved.

That night Emily did not sleep much. Every small sound in the apartment made her sit up in bed and listen. The quiet hum of the refrigerator seemed louder than usual. The creak of the building settling made her glance toward the bedroom door. Her thoughts kept returning to the photograph on the kitchen table.

Around two in the morning she finally gave up trying to sleep. She got out of bed and walked slowly into the kitchen. The room was dark except for the faint light coming from the street outside. Emily turned on the small lamp near the table. The photograph still lay where she had left it.

She picked it up carefully. Her breath stopped. The man was now standing at the edge of the trees, just behind the group. He was still several feet away from them, but he was close enough now that he looked as if he could take two or three steps forward and join them. Emily felt a sudden wave of fear that rushed through her chest so strongly that she nearly dropped the photograph. Her fingers tightened around the edges of the paper.

Slowly, she placed the photograph face down on the table. For a long time she simply sat there staring at the wood surface. The light from the lamp cast a pale circle across the table. Her breathing felt shallow.

“This cannot be happening,” she whispered.

Several minutes passed before she finally gathered the courage to flip the photograph over again. Nothing had changed. The man still stood behind the group. Emily slowly leaned back in her chair.

“That makes no sense,” she said softly.

She remained at the table until the early morning hours before finally returning to bed. When morning arrived, she had made up her mind. She had enough of this nonsense. The photograph was clearly disturbing her, and she did not want it in her apartment anymore. Emily walked into the kitchen, picked up the photograph, and carried it to the trash can beside the counter.

“This is ridiculous,” she said firmly.

She dropped the photograph into the trash. Then she grabbed her coat and left for work. All day she felt a small sense of relief. The photograph was gone. She could put this whole ordeal behind her.

When Emily returned home that evening, the apartment felt quiet and peaceful. She walked into the kitchen and set her bag down on the table. Then she froze. The photograph was sitting on the kitchen table. Exactly in the center. Emily slowly stepped closer, her hands trembled slightly.

“I threw you away,” she whispered.

She did not remember taking the photograph out of the trash, nor did she remember placing it on the table. But there it was. The fear took hold again. The man had moved again. He now stood directly behind the wooden bench, only a few feet away from the boy holding the fishing pole. Emily bent down closer to the photograph. His face was much clearer now. She could see his eyes. They were wide and dark. And he was still staring directly toward the camera; or maybe toward her.

Emily felt her chest tighten as she stared at the image. Then she noticed something else. Something that had not been there before. The people sitting on the bench. The two women still faced the camera with polite smiles. But the boy had changed. The boy was no longer smiling; his mouth was slightly open, and his face looked tense, like he had just noticed something behind him.
And one of the women had turned her head slightly, as if she was beginning to look over her shoulder. Emily felt a deep, sickening realization grow in her mind. The people in the photograph were starting to notice the man, and the man was still getting closer. Emily looked back at the photograph once more before turning it face down again.

That was when she noticed one final detail. Something that made the blood drain from her face. The photograph had changed in another way. The camera angle had shifted slightly, as if whoever was holding the camera had taken a step backward. And in the lower corner of the photograph, just barely visible, was the edge of a mirror.

Inside the mirror was a reflection. A reflection of a room she couldn’t quite tell what it was. She reached into the drawer on the counter and pulled out a magnifying glass. Looking close, her breath seized. The reflection was of Emily’s kitchen. And in the reflection, standing behind her chair, was the man in the long dark coat. Emily stared at the photograph for a long time without moving. Her fingers rested lightly on the edges of the paper. The overhead light above the table cast a soft yellow circle across the kitchen, but the rest of the room seemed darker than before. The quiet hum of the refrigerator filled the silence. The ticking of the small kitchen clock sounded slow and heavy.

Her mind tried to explain what she was seeing. But no explanation felt real. The mirror in the corner of the photograph clearly showed her kitchen. The table was there. The light above it was there. Even the small stack of unopened mail that sat near the wall was visible in the reflection. Everything was exactly the same as the room she sat in, except for one thing. Behind the chair in the reflection stood the man in the long dark coat.

Emily slowly turned around. Her chair scraped slightly against the floor as she moved. The sound felt loud inside the quiet apartment. The motion made her heart pound harder. She looked behind her toward the empty space near the wall, but nothing was there. Only the soft humming of the refrigerator and the steady ticking of the clock.

Emily swallowed slowly. Her breathing was shallow now. She turned back toward the photograph. The reflection was still there. Inside the tiny mirror in the corner of the picture, the man continued to stand behind her chair. His tall shape rose above the back of it. His long coat hung straight down. His pale face seemed unnaturally still. His eyes looked like dark circles.

The longer Emily stared at them, the deeper they seemed. Her hands trembled.

“This is not real,” she whispered quietly.

She pushed the photograph away from her across the table. The paper slid a few inches across the smooth wood surface. Her heart continued beating hard in her chest. For several seconds she did nothing but stare at it. Then slowly she reached forward again and picked it up. This time she examined the people beside the lake.

The boy had changed. He was no longer holding the fishing pole casually. His small hands gripped it tightly now, his fingers wrapped around the pole as if he was nervous. His wide smile had vanished completely. His mouth looked tense and uncertain.

Emily looked closer. The woman sitting beside him had turned her head farther now. Her face showed confusion. It looked as if she had begun to notice something behind the bench. The two men standing in the back still faced the camera, but their expressions had changed slightly. Their smiles had faded. They looked unsure, almost worried.

Emily felt her stomach tighten. She studied the trees in the background again. The shadows looked darker now, and the man in the coat had moved closer again. Now he stood directly behind the wooden bench. His long coat hung motionless with his hands rested quietly at his sides. His face was no longer hidden by distance or shadow. Emily could see every detail. His skin looked pale and smooth almost like wax. His lips were thin and still. While his eyes were wide and empty. But the strangest thing was his expression. He looked patient. Like someone waiting calmly for the right moment.

Emily quickly placed the photograph on the table and pushed her chair back. The legs of the chair scraped softly against the floor as she stood up. Her heart was beating so hard that she could feel it in her chest and throat.

“This cannot be happening,” she whispered.

Her hands moved quickly as she grabbed her phone from the table. The small screen lit up as she opened the camera. She pointed it toward the photograph and took a picture. The phone made a soft clicking sound. Then she took three more photos. If the photograph changed again, she wanted proof. The phone captured the image clearly. Emily lowered the phone slowly.

She stepped away from the table and walked slowly into the living room. Her legs felt slightly weak. Emily took her purse and took out a prescription bottle she was prescribed by her doctor for stress and anxiety attacks. She took a pill dry as she turned on the television, hoping the sound would distract her thoughts. The screen filled the room with moving light and quiet voices from a program she barely paid attention to.

But her eyes kept drifting toward the kitchen. The photograph sat exactly where she had left it. Nearly an hour passed before Emily forced herself to stand up again. She walked slowly back toward the kitchen. She reached the table and looked down. Her stomach tightened.

The man had moved again. He now stood beside the bench, right next to the boy. Emily felt a chill run through her body. The boy’s face had changed completely. His mouth was open slightly now, like he was about to scream. One of the men standing in the back had turned around. His body twisted slightly as if he had just heard something behind him.

Emily grabbed her phone again with shaking hands and opened the pictures she had taken earlier. She stared at the screen. Those pictures were different. In the photographs on her phone, the man still stood behind the bench. But in the photograph on the table, he had already moved beside it. Emily felt dizzy. The photograph was changing, and the changes were happening faster now. A cold feeling spread through her chest. The mirror in the corner was growing larger, taking up more space of the photograph. She did not need a magnifying glass to see it now.

The man in the coat was no longer standing behind the chair. The reflection now showed the empty kitchen. Emily felt her heart pound harder. The camera angle had also shifted again. Now it looked like the camera was standing closer to the table. Much closer than before. Emily felt her stomach twist as a terrible thought entered her mind. The person holding the camera in the photograph was slowly moving toward the mirror, toward her.

She quickly looked back at the people beside the lake. The scene had changed even more. The woman sitting on the bench had turned completely around now, her face showed clear fear. The boy had dropped the fishing pole on the ground beside the bench. The two men standing behind them were no longer smiling at all, and the man in the coat now stood directly in front of them. Facing them with his back was turned toward the camera.

Emily stared at the photograph carefully. Nothing moved. But she knew it would. The picture had been changing every time she looked away. She leaned forward, watching the photograph without blinking. Minutes passed as her eyes began to burn from staring. Finally she blinked once.

When her eyes opened again, the photograph had changed. The people beside the lake were gone. The bench was empty. The fishing pole lay alone on the ground. The lake and trees remained the same. But the man in the coat now stood alone in the center of the photograph, facing the camera.

Emily felt panic well up inside her. She looked again at the mirror reflection in the corner. The reflection showed the kitchen. The table, overhead light, and now the camera stood only a few feet away from the mirror. Emily slowly realized what that meant. The person holding the camera in the photograph was now standing almost exactly where she was sitting.

Her hands shook as she lifted the photograph closer to her face. The man in the coat was smiling now. It was a slow, unnatural smile. The kind of smile that felt wrong, or evil like it did not belong on a human face. Emily suddenly heard a faint sound behind her. A quiet movement. Like fabric brushing gently against the back of a chair.

Her entire body froze. Very slowly she lowered the photograph. Her breathing was shallow and quiet. She did not want to turn around because very instinct in her mind told her not to move. But she knew she had to. Her chair creaked softly as she shifted as Emily slowly turned her head.

The kitchen was empty. The refrigerator hummed. The clock ticked. Nothing or nobody stood behind her. Emily looked down at the photograph again. She let out a small cry. The photograph had changed one final time. The photograph wasn’t of the lake, the people or the man. It was the camera reflection in the mirror. Inside the mirror was Emily. She sat at the table holding the photograph. Her face was pale. Her eyes were wide with fear. Standing directly behind her was a tall figure in a long dark coat. His pale hand rested gently on her shoulder.

And he was smiling at the camera.

Credit: Rodney Hatfield Jr.

Facebook